
Austin Current is a nonprofit local news organization supported by The Texas Tribune, reporting on Austin government, education and community. Sign up for the Current’s free newsletter here.
Austin leaders are looking to a new state government for a more cooperative relationship that could ease years of conflict over Project Connect. But the long-delayed light rail project still faces a lawsuit challenging its financing, and the case could affect the agency’s ability to borrow money for construction.
Democratic state Sen. Nathan Johnson is set to become Texas attorney general next year, replacing Ken Paxton, whose office issued a 2023 legal opinion questioning the legality of Project Connect’s financing mechanism. That opinion helped pave the way for a taxpayer-led lawsuit challenging the use of voter-approved property tax revenue to repay the project’s bonds. Johnson said he is reviewing the case but has not taken a position on it.
The lawsuit has not yet delayed Project Connect, but it could threaten the project’s progress as the agency prepares to issue bonds for construction of the light rail, which is scheduled to start in 2027. The case is proceeding through the courts even as the statewide political climate shifts. Some city leaders do see the shift in state leadership as an opportunity to stop “fighting for survival.”
“We’ve been governing with the state’s boot on our neck for the last couple of decades. To be able to govern in a way and work with the state as a partner, to have cooperation and support from the state could really be a huge benefit to the City of Austin,” Council Member Chito Vela said. “I’m just much more optimistic about where we are with Project Connect.”
Vela said he expects the conflict over Project Connect to ease under the incoming state leadership, though he didn’t identify a specific action he expects the new administration to take.
“I just anticipate that that conflict will go away,” Vela said.
Johnson told the Austin Current he does not yet know enough about the transportation initiative to make worthwhile comments, but said he’s reviewing it “to determine the right course of action under the law and in the public interest.”
Project Connect’s bumpy start
Six years after 59% of voters greenlit Austin’s first light rail system, the initiative has faced rising construction costs, inflation and political opposition.
Those financial constraints forced transportation officials to dramatically scale back their light rail plans, from 26 stops and about 20 miles of light rail to 15 stops and just under 10 miles. Initially, officials planned to lay about 12 miles of light rail track from about U.S. 183 in North Austin down to South Congress Avenue at Stassney Lane. That has been reduced by about four miles on the northern end and three miles on the southern end.
In addition to reducing its size, transportation officials eliminated plans for an underground subway system through downtown and a connection to Austin-Bergstrom International Airport, both hallmarks of the original proposal.
“The biggest uphill battle the city has had to face with Project Connect is inflation,” said Brian Smith, professor of political science at St. Edwards University. “What they sold the city on when they passed the Project Connect bond isn’t what the cost is, so it’s going to be very, very expensive.”
The cost of the reduced light rail system is estimated at about $8.2 billion, up from the initial $5.8 billion projection, according to The Texas Tribune reporting.
Mayor Kirk Watson announced a week after the Nov. 3 election that there could be an opportunity to restore plans for the airport connection, with the goal of completing it without additional taxpayer funding. While the timing is notable, neither the mayor nor Austin Transportation Partnership indicated the announcement had anything to do with the statewide election results. Instead, Watson pointed to ATP progress on major project milestones.
Stubborn legal challenges
As Watson looks to expand the project, legal challenges to its financing remain active.
The transportation initiative has faced repeated challenges from the state since its passage. Following a request from state Sen. Paul Bettencourt, outgoing Attorney General Paxton released an opinion challenging the project’s financing structure, which would use property tax revenue approved by voters to repay bonds issued by ATP to fund construction of the light rail.
Months later, local attorney Bill Aleshire filed a taxpayer lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of ATP’s funding mechanism, in line with the AG opinion. Aleshire said the shift in state leadership will not affect his case.
“Nothing that happened last Tuesday has anything to do with the legal issues that I’m working on,” Aleshire said. “It’s an unconstitutional debt. That’s the issue that’s going up. If we win our points, the Project Connect tax is dead.”
The litigation remains unresolved after an August hearing led to appeals from both the attorney general’s office and the city and ATP. While the lawsuit hasn’t caused any delays yet, the unresolved legal questions could prevent ATP from issuing bonds to fund construction, which is scheduled to start in 2027.
“ATP initiated bond validation proceedings in 2024 to have an impartial judge confirm that our bond program complies with all state laws on an expedited basis,” a spokesperson for the agency said. “ATP and the City have followed the law at every step in moving the project forward. ATP remains confident and ready for our day in court.”
Aleshire’s concerns with Project Connect go beyond the funding issue. He said what is on the table now is not what voters signed on to six years ago, and the current plan should be scrapped.
“We’re going to have to do what we begged them to do from the beginning,” he said, “Rethink Project Connect and go back to the voters with a plan that has an honest price tag and an honest time frame.”
Aleshire questioned whether ATP could build the airport extension without seeking more money from residents.
ATP has not yet publicly indicated whether it has sufficient funding to build the proposed elevated 3-mile extension to the airport within its existing budget. In his newsletter, Watson challenged the organization to do so without going to voters for more money.
ATP also has yet to receive the federal funding it needs to cover about half the project’s total cost. The transportation authority remains in talks with federal officials.
Vela believes a court victory for Austin and ATP could help clear the way for billions in federal funding, particularly with a more supportive Congress.
“With resolving all the state political and legal issues, it opens the door to say, ‘Congress, we’re ready for the money,’” Vela said.
Source link
